Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Virgin Media Internet Service (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   General : Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33686670)

sniper007 03-04-2012 10:27

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pythagoras (Post 35408596)
This dosnt seem at all fair. I am paying exactly the same as 100Mb customers, being on xxl50, yet I can only download half the amount before I'm traffic managed, at that point I'll get 25mb speeds so a quarter of the 100mb peeps for the same price.

Surely this cant be correct? I'm only due to be doubled between oct and july 2013, so I'll be paying for a far inferior service for between 7 months and 15 months.

Regards

John

Quote:

Originally Posted by pythagoras (Post 35408616)
Im already paying the same as 100MB customers, but only getting a 50Mb service, with worse STM terms. Thats my point.

John can you explain this to me? I am on XXL 50mb and have been told the same that my speed will double between October 2012 and July 2013. I have always paid a premium for 50mb due to lack of STM but now this looks to me like this is a big impact for potentially over a year. Why do you (myself as well?) pay the same as 100mb customer I do not understand. Apologies, I am not too clued up on the area of broadband tier pricing but understand that there is/was a 100mb tier AND a 120mb tier?

I have also now just read in another thread that one cannot downgrade to 30mb now to get the "free" upgrade to 60mb, although I may be interpreting this incorrectly.

Overall I feel let down as a loyal VM customer right now, and that there is no point paying a premium for 50mb anymore.

buckleb 03-04-2012 10:33

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jumping (Post 35408500)
Yeah cause there really isnt any legal way to download a lot of data...Patch World of Warcraft or use the download to play, buy some games from Steam, download Windows 8 beta etc there are plenty of legal ways to use a lot of data and its certainly normal internet activity.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sirius (Post 35408504)
And don't mention using bit torrent to mirror the Raspberry pie isos like i am :rolleyes:

Remember people think Bit Torrent is for illegal use only:rolleyes:

Yes, because mirroring isos is pretty normal, right? Downloading the Warcraft client every day, and buying games from Steam every day, and downloading Windows 8 every day is normal, right?

Do you think that VM are implementing these measure because of people updating Warcraft, or downloading Windows 8, or watching streamed media?

You see it every day on here, and other sites, nod and winks about downloading 'linux iso images', complaints about throttled newsgroups, boasts about how many GB a night people can squirrel away.

People squealing about how 'their' usage is completely above board and "how dare" others suggest otherwise seem to be protesting a little too much. I'm sure that there are some, quite uncommon, legitimate reasons why somebody would be maxing out their 100Mb connection 24/7, but on the whole, nah, people are generally going at it hammer and tongs.

Unless we include that aspect in the discussion of STM, then it's a waste of time, as people seem reluctant to even acknowledge the existence of such activities, when in fact they seem the main reason for having STM at all.

BenMcr 03-04-2012 10:37

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sniper007 (Post 35408921)
but understand that there is/was a 100mb tier AND a 120mb tier?

There are currently two 100Mbit tiers. XXL 100 and the original 100Mbit. 120Mbit hasn't launched yet but when it does both 100Mbit tiers will be uplifted to 120Mbit as part of the programme

Quote:

I have also now just read in another thread that one cannot downgrade to 30mb now to get the "free" upgrade to 60mb, although I may be interpreting this incorrectly.
That's because all speed changes are onto the new tiers. So techincally if you downgraded from XXL to XL you would actually go from 50Mbit to 60Mbit. Asking to go onto 30Mbit would take you down to L

sniper007 03-04-2012 10:44

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by buckleb (Post 35408924)
Yes, because mirroring isos is pretty normal, right? Downloading the Warcraft client every day, and buying games from Steam every day, and downloading Windows 8 every day is normal, right?

Do you think that VM are implementing these measure because of people updating Warcraft, or downloading Windows 8, or watching streamed media?

You see it every day on here, and other sites, nod and winks about downloading 'linux iso images', complaints about throttled newsgroups, boasts about how many GB a night people can squirrel away.

People squealing about how 'their' usage is completely above board and "how dare" others suggest otherwise seem to be protesting a little too much. I'm sure that there are some, quite uncommon, legitimate reasons why somebody would be maxing out their 100Mb connection 24/7, but on the whole, nah, people are generally going at it hammer and tongs.

Unless we include that aspect in the discussion of STM, then it's a waste of time, as people seem reluctant to even acknowledge the existence of such activities, when in fact they seem the main reason for having STM at all.

It's not always about maxing the connection out day in, day out, weeks upon end. It's about downloading a big chunk just as a one off during peak times (when you might want to use it) is going to grant you 5 hours of STM. People dislike being penalised for using their high speed connection to download a one off large chunk at a desirable time to them. If that is the only large chunk they download all month, that's not a particularly fair and intelligent STM model. For "repeat offenders" literally leaching/seeding 24/7 torrents then yes, they should be STM'd. If you can't intelligtently and fairly do STM, then don't do it all is the argument.

---------- Post added at 10:44 ---------- Previous post was at 10:40 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by BenMcr (Post 35408925)
There are currently two 100Mbit tiers. XXL 100 and the original 100Mbit. 120Mbit hasn't launched yet but when it does both 100Mbit tiers will be uplifted to 120Mbit as part of the programme

That's because all speed changes are onto the new tiers. So techincally if you downgraded from XXL to XL you would actually go from 50Mbit to 60Mbit. Asking to go onto 30Mbit would take you down to L

So does this mean I am paying more than an EX 30mb user and receiving 10mb less? Ah I find this all so confusing. John above mentioned he is paying the same as a 100mb user? How is this so?
I also read of "everywhere is 100mb enabled now" yet I will not get doubled up from 50 to 100 until October 2012 - July 2013. Why is there a delay if 100mb is enabled and ready?

Sorry for all the questions.

I think a really helpful thread (sticky) would be the history of all tiers/pricing/stm etc. I certainly do not understand it well enough to do it, but you might Ben.

Peter_ 03-04-2012 10:49

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
This is reason enough for me to be glad that I no longer work for the company and will not have to answer any queries about this new traffic management.https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/local/2012/04/8.gif

Jumping 03-04-2012 10:49

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by buckleb (Post 35408924)
Yes, because mirroring isos is pretty normal, right? Downloading the Warcraft client every day, and buying games from Steam every day, and downloading Windows 8 every day is normal, right?

Do you think that VM are implementing these measure because of people updating Warcraft, or downloading Windows 8, or watching streamed media?

You see it every day on here, and other sites, nod and winks about downloading 'linux iso images', complaints about throttled newsgroups, boasts about how many GB a night people can squirrel away.

People squealing about how 'their' usage is completely above board and "how dare" others suggest otherwise seem to be protesting a little too much. I'm sure that there are some, quite uncommon, legitimate reasons why somebody would be maxing out their 100Mb connection 24/7, but on the whole, nah, people are generally going at it hammer and tongs.

Unless we include that aspect in the discussion of STM, then it's a waste of time, as people seem reluctant to even acknowledge the existence of such activities, when in fact they seem the main reason for having STM at all.

Yeah I download WoW every day just so I can have the files fresh and make sure they are up to date.....

Seriously it was only a couple of examples of downloads that could make you hit the STM so why should you be punished for using your connection for something you paid for?

Fact is with more and more content online streaming, VOD, you buy a game and have to DOWNLOAD it, etc its really not hard to see that this is a step backwards people buy their broad band because of their usage which is why I think a lot of people are unhappy. I don't download 100gb's every month but I would like to be able to do a big download if I have without getting punished for it on the day.

buckleb 03-04-2012 11:00

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jumping (Post 35408937)
Yeah I download WoW every day just so I can have the files fresh and make sure they are up to date.....

Seriously it was only a couple of examples of downloads that could make you hit the STM so why should you be punished for using your connection for something you paid for?

Fact is with more and more content online streaming, VOD, you buy a game and have to DOWNLOAD it, etc its really not hard to see that this is a step backwards people buy their broad band because of their usage which is why I think a lot of people are unhappy. I don't download 100gb's every month but I would like to be able to do a big download if I have without getting punished for it on the day.

So would I, and how VM implement their STM is a (slightly) different discussion. I agree that it should be more intelligent than the current blunt instrument it is. I suspect though, that it is far easier (not to mention cheaper) to set up an STM system activated by dumb triggers.

As mentioned earlier, the cut in speed by 50% rather than 75% is better, and I can't really think of much that would suffer from 'only' having a 50Mb download speed. I don't know how STM affects other aspects of the service, but I'd imagine that a decrease in ping/jitter quality would not be that noticeable, especially if the rest of the family is HD streaming, uploading to FTP sites, etc.

Chrysalis 03-04-2012 12:45

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Blackened (Post 35408880)
Yeah.

Old: http://www.virginmedia.com/images/tm-table-fu-large.jpg

You just go down to 50% speed instead of 75% speed when STM'd.

I'm sure someone said the threshold's were changing too. I Must have misunderstood.

thanks for confirming.

so basically the new limits for the 60 and 100 are not increased in proportion to the speed those guys get less per mbit.

Blairhoyle 03-04-2012 12:47

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
I have the 50meg package.

I will be watching the football tonight online in HD does that mean once it hits 5000MB my video is going to start stuttering etc?!

carlwaring 03-04-2012 12:50

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
As HD only requires something like 2.5mb, then no, probably not :)

crazyronnie 03-04-2012 12:55

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
HD streaming uses more than that.

Netflix HD requires 5Mb for 720p streaming and 8Mb for 1080p.

Blairhoyle 03-04-2012 12:57

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
seriously this internet talk does my brain in.

for the first few months with Virgin I couldn't have been happier, that has started eroding away.

carlwaring 03-04-2012 12:57

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by crazyronnie (Post 35409010)
HD streaming uses more than that.

Netflix HD requires 5Mb for 720p streaming and 8Mb for 1080p.

Oh, okay. Sorry. Thought I'd read that figure somewhere. Okay. Well, I don't think the 50 meg services is reduced to <10 is it?

Blairhoyle 03-04-2012 13:03

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by carlwaring (Post 35409013)
Oh, okay. Sorry. Thought I'd read that figure somewhere. Okay. Well, I don't think the 50 meg services is reduced to <10 is it?


I take it that it only get reduced if you go over your traffic management allowance?

from 4pm-9pm I take it all speeds are lowered?

BenMcr 03-04-2012 13:06

Re: Traffic Management Changes - April 2nd
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Blairhoyle (Post 35409019)
I take it that it only get reduced if you go over your traffic management allowance?

Yes

Quote:

from 4pm-9pm I take it all speeds are lowered?
Yes but 50Mbit gets reduced to 25Mbit - still enough for two Netflix HD streams plus an SD one


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 18:06.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.